David Ogilvy saw it coming long ago and called it ‘Changing Brand Preference’. It is an element which is necessary if the product advertised has established substitutes. Switch Effect is called for when purpose is to make consumer switch from buying a product over other, specially buying a new product over established one.
According to Advertising legend Alyque Padamsee“‘switch factor is the name of the advertising game today. We are in a highly competitive market, not a virgin one”.
The 'switch factor' is absolutely lacking in today's ads. When agencies have prepared the pitch for a television commercial, they must sit with their client and find out do our ads have the essential element to make people switch from some other brand to his. If it does not, then we must waste no time in tearing the commercial up and preparing a new one.
Most of the ad agencies I visited do not believe in the theory of Switch effect to drive sales. One V.P of a leading Multinational agency argued-“to drive sales, the product should have the switch effect and the purpose of advertising is only to let the product talk to consumer”. He might be right to an extent but at the end of day if the sales figure is not shooting up for a year or two the agency will be sacked.
Lowe Lintas was the agency which created the Liril Girl campaign and the campaign ran for a full 25 yrs but in spite of being extremely creative, the agency lost the contract as Hindustan Lever, dissatisfied with the soap's sales figures moved the product out of the agency.
A lot of Ad agencies brand themselves as creative hot shop but in my definition, advertising is only about creativity for selling purposes. We are not competing with M F Husain or other top painters or poets. The job is to sell the clients' products. However creative we may be, if we fail to sell our clients' products, then it is not a good ad. Some agencies have blended creativity and saleability nicely.
To me, a great ad is an ad that generates great sales. A lot of advertising today is certainly noticeable as ad agencies try to break through the 'clutter' but unfortunately often at the end of the commercial, you don't know what on earth they are selling, though you remember the ad which was great fun. The ad has no Switch Effect at all. Sometimes, even if you remember the brand, you don't find any reason, apart from humor, to choose that brand. It's good to have funny ads but we must remember that we are no R K Laxman. We create comic, serious or dramatic ads only to sell some products.
One of the best examples for understanding Switch Effect is ‘Fair and Handsome Cream’. The ad certainly has created a need for men to switch the earlier cosmetics they were using to the new brand which was specially formulated for their skin. Today it is one of the fastest growing FMCG products in recent history -- it has achieved sales of Rs 50 crore (Rs 500 million) in 9 to 10 months, but its an old story ...I need a fresh example.....
Rituraj Srivastva